How to Choose an Estate Sale Company
The company you hire will price, advertise and sell most of what is in the home, usually in a single weekend. Choosing carefully is worth a few extra days. Here is how to do it without becoming an expert first.
- Step 1Describe the homeOne short form: the property, how much is being sold, and when.
- Step 2Companies reach outUp to five that work in your area get your request and contact you.
- Step 3Meet and compareWalk each one through the house and ask the same questions.
- Step 4Sign a contractDates, fees and payout in writing before anything is priced.
Twelve things to do before you sign
- Learn the basics first
Twenty minutes of reading makes you a much better interviewer. If you have never been to one, start with what an estate sale is and how a sale day runs.
- Talk to at least three companies
Prices, style and availability vary more than people expect. One conversation gives you nothing to compare against. Browse companies near you, or send one request and let them come to you.
- Look past the commission
Most companies take a percentage of the total, commonly somewhere between 30% and 50% depending on the region and the size of the sale. A lower rate is not automatically the better deal: a company that prices well and draws a bigger crowd can leave you with more money at a higher percentage. Ask what the rate includes and what is billed on top.
- Have them see the house
A quote given over the phone is a guess. Invite your short list to walk through. You learn how they talk about your things, and they can tell you honestly whether there is enough for a sale.
- Do not throw anything out yet
The box of costume jewelry, the old tools, the kitchen drawer of oddities: these sell. Families regularly discard things that would have paid for the dumpster several times over. Let the company sort first.
- Take what you are keeping before you sign
Once the contract is signed, the contents are the sale. Many contracts charge commission on anything pulled out afterward, because the company planned and advertised around it. Remove keepsakes first, or list the exceptions in the contract.
- Ask how sales tax is handled
Rules differ by state and sometimes by county. A professional company knows whether tax applies to your sale, collects it, and files it. If the answer is vague, treat that as information.
- Check their track record
Read reviews from shoppers and from past clients, since they see different sides of the business. Look for a pattern over time, and for how the company responds when something went wrong.
- Go to one of their sales
Show up unannounced as a shopper. Is the house organized and clearly priced? Is the line handled fairly? Is checkout quick and polite? That is exactly how your sale will run. You can find estate sales near you on the map.
- Call their references
Ask for recent clients, then ask those clients two things: were you paid when they said you would be, and what would you have wanted done differently?
- Get everything in the contract
Sale dates, commission and every other fee, when and how you are paid, what happens to unsold items, who cleans up, and what each side is responsible for. Both of you keep a signed copy. If it was promised out loud, it belongs on paper.
- Ask everyone the same questions
It is the only way to compare fairly. Use the checklist below, and write the answers down while you are still in the room.
Questions to ask every company
Tick them off as you go. Print one copy per company so the answers sit side by side.
Money
The sale
Protection
Afterward
Warning signs
- No written contract, or pressure to sign on the first visit.
- Fees that only come up after you ask twice.
- An offer to buy the best pieces privately before the sale opens to the public.
- No recent sales you can look at, and no clients you can call.
- Vague answers about when you are paid.
If you are settling an estate
Before any sale, confirm you have the legal authority to sell the contents, and that heirs have agreed on what is being kept. A company can advise on timing, but questions about probate belong with the estate's attorney.
Common questions
How much does an estate sale company charge?
Most charge a percentage of total sales rather than a flat fee, commonly somewhere between 30% and 50% depending on the region and the size of the sale. Ask what the rate includes, because setup, advertising, clean-out and card fees are sometimes billed separately.
How many estate sale companies should I interview?
At least three. Have each one walk through the home, ask them all the same questions, and compare the answers along with the contract terms.
Should I clean out the house before calling a company?
No. Remove only what the family is keeping. Everyday items that look like clutter often sell, and companies prefer to sort the home themselves.